Reviews

ARC Review: Not So Stories – edited by David Thomas Moore

Not So StoriesAnthology of culturally diverse writers create short works in reaction to Kipling’s Just So Stories

Rudyard Kipling’s Just So Stories was one of the first true children’s books in the English language, a timeless classic that continues to delight readers to this day. Beautiful, evocative and playful, the stories of How the Whale Got His Throat or the First Letter Written paint a magical, primal world.

It’s also deeply rooted in British colonialism. Kipling saw the Empire as a benign, civilising force, and his writing can be troubling to modern readers. Not So Stories attempts to redress the balance, bringing together new and established writers of colour from around the world to take the Just So Stories back, giving voices to cultures that were long deprived them.

I received a copy of Not So Stories from NetGalley. From the start, I was captivated by the premise. I don’t remember if I ever read Kipling’s Just So Stories, but the idea of authors reacting to his stories and taking the stories back was amazing. I also really adore stories about animals.

The stories are #ownvoices. 


These stories were engaging and so much fun to read! I really enjoy reading stories with anthropomorphic animals, however I haven’t been reading them a lot recently. To come across a collection of stories that are so very strong in their inherent diversity was a lovely surprise. I didn’t quite realise that even animal stories are usually told solely from the white person’s perspective, until I read these stories.

I am always intrigued when humans vs. animals stories change perspective, and show that the animals consider the humans to be lesser. Thus, I really like the story Queen, especially, since it wasn’t quite clear who the human and who the animal was at the beginning. Also, the whole vibe of the story was very powerful.

I also adored Best Beloved, as it discussed racism within an interracial relationship, and also discussed the connection that the main character had with ghosts.

Samsara was another beautiful story with a biracial (Indian and English) main character. It portrayed many themes that I myself have thought about, such as why it’s fashionable for white people to wear South Asian clothes, but not for South Asians. I really liked how much this story spoke to me. It felt very empowering.

I’m not a huge cat fan (I am allergic to them) but one of the sweetest stories was Strays Like Us. Bastet, the goddess, is the main character in this story. It deals with her bonding with one of her cats. I loved how they slowly came closer and closer to each other, and how you could see that Bastet was not only helping the cat, but the cat was helping Bastet as well. I had a good giggle about Bastet’s opinions of humans and what she thinks about cats.

There are some ableist phrases in some of the stories, as well as phrases that say there are only two genders.


Not So Stories is a great addition to any child’s bookshelf. The stories are so beautiful and there is so much to them. I think that you could have amazing discussions about them.

Trigger warnings: gore/violence, racism.

4-stars
4 stars

Are you planning to read Not So Stories? Are there any other diverse children’s short story collections that you would recommend I read?

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “ARC Review: Not So Stories – edited by David Thomas Moore

  1. I have an ARC of this as well and it’s next up on my list – I read your review now but I’ll most likely come back to read it again after I’m done with the book, so I can fully understand it 🙂 I’m really glad you liked it though and I’m looking forwar to reading it!

    Like

      1. I’m late with the reply, but I actually read the book since then! My favourites were: Queen, Best Beloved, Samsāra, The Cat Who Walked by Herself, How the Simurgh Won Her Tail, and How The Camel Got Her Paid Time off. The last one was very different in atmosphere, but I think it was nice to have something about worker rights. (I see we have similar favourites, since 3 out of the 4 you listed is on my list as well :D)

        Like

  2. Great review Sinead ! (I waited until I had finished mine to visit yours so I wouldn’t say the same without meaning to haha!)
    This was such a good book, I’m glad to see you also loved Georgina Kamsika’s story! (Although it isn’t spelt the same way in my epub and the kindle copy so I don’t know if that’s actually Sasara or Samsara?)

    Like

      1. I asked and it’s Saṃsara with a dot under the m!

        I loved this one, How the camel got her paid time off, strays like us, … there were so many good ones. At least I can’t think of one I disliked!

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s